Tuesday, February 26, 2013

Zara: IT for Fast Fashion


Inditex is a holding company atop clothing chain called Zara. Zara`s operating system still runs on DOS. DOS (Disk Operating System) was the first widely-installed operating system for personal computers. Zara is worried about its IT infrastructure being too old and the possibility that hardware vendors will upgrade their "computers" leaving them unsuited with DOS.

Zara's operations rely on its POS (the point-of-sale) terminals which are used by each store, all over the world. One of the problem is that these terminals inside a store do not communicate with any other terminals. Only one terminal for each store has ability to communicate with headquarters in La Coruna. Also, Personal Digital Assistants (PDA) used to complete the ordering process are not connected in any way to the POS terminals. As a result, Zara has the lack of ability to check inventory within stores. Instead of using a modern system that updates inventory in real time when items are scanned for sale or return, employees have to search in shelves and count their inventories. This is time consuming and inaccurate.

Zara has three alternatives:

  1. Staying with the POS terminals - Zara can stay with the original system since the POS terminals with DOS works very well. As Sanchez said: "POS is not broken, why are we trying to fix it?" The benefit with staying with the current system is that it is stable and requires less IT support. 
  2. Upgrading the POS terminals - The benefits of upgrading the system do not outweigh the costs. The costs include the new terminals and new software. Zara should not forget to count with the cost of switching to the new system, retraining the current employees, and hiring a full time IT staff to maintain a new system. 
  3. Replacing the POS terminals - Zara can change the whole IT system that will improve communication between stores, reduce floppy disk use, and allow using of new features. However, the system will be a big investment for Zara. The cost will be very high because they will have to find a new vendor, install the new system, train employees, and it will lead to a drastic change.

My recommendation for the company would be to change their operational system. Although DOS works well for them, the future is not in it. It makes them dependent of their hardware vendor and opening a new store may become risky if they cannot provide it with the same hardware tools. A new system will support employees with more information and it will increase efficiency. Zara should implement changes slowly in an effort to make the transition easier. The initial cost of the investment may be substantial but the return on investment gained from increased operational efficiency over time will outweigh these costs. Zara must find an alternative that works best with the criteria that it is concerned with while also allowing for Zara to accomplish its goals. Since the alternatives are laid out, Zara must do their research to see which alternative theoretically fits them best.

If I were presenting, I would explain Zara's operations and prepare cost-benefit analysis to see if replacing the old POS system would be beneficial.

Reflection:

After the presentation of our consultants, I still think that even though Zara has no problem with POS system itself at its current status, the innovations will require Zara to upgrade it. For a fast growing company like Zara, I would reccommended to improve their system now rather than waiting until they actually hit a problem. I would recommended this investment by explaining the possible future risks and what can happen if Zara would have to switch out their technology at last minute. I believe ZARA will be able to achieve improvement with new technology. For example, this change will allow for online sites and create better and faster inventory updates. It will also connect all of ZARA’s chain stores. Some of the benefits will allow Zara to better manage and predict demand. As long as ZARA can adapt to this technology the way they want, they may be able to keep their tradition of person to person interaction with customers, and at the same time, be more efficient at helping and getting them what they want. During the integration process it may be helpful for Zara to introduce the new infrastructure by country. The IT department will need to hire and train new and current employees in order to make a successful transition. The following step will be updating their operation system, hence in the future the question could be "how do we continue to be successful" instead of "how do we solve our old system problem"?!


No comments:

Post a Comment