Pandora is an internet radio operated by Pandora Media, Inc.. It is fully available in the United States, Australia and New Zealand. The service plays musical selections of a certain genre based on the user's artist selection. The user then provides positive or negative feedback for songs chosen by the service, which are taken into account when Pandora selects future songs. Pandora previously switched from a subscription based model to a primarily free model with very limited subscriptions. Therefore, Pandora relies heavily on advertising for revenue. Other sources of revenue include the percentage of funds received from iTunes and Amazon purchases referred by Pandora. It has a successful model as far as number of customers, but it needs to find a way to convert that into profit.
Year over year, Pandora has seen their bottom line shrink from a loss to even larger loss despite an increase in revenues. The context of its problem is how Pandora can become a profitable organization. To make this happen, Pandora needs to keep its regular customers, attract new ones and cover its expenses including operating costs and royalties.
The problem is, that its listeners are the most expensive elements because Pandora has to pay royalties on a per song basis. The "non-stop carefree streaming" is costing Pandora a lot of money. Listeners do not care whether they left the program running and playing songs or not.
Alternative Courses of Action (or nicely being said: What Pandora can do?)
1. Add more advertising and marketing - by using information obtained from the registration process, it could provide target marketing as well as local marketing and maximize advertising opportunities. Pandora is only using about 60% of their available advertising space. By maximizing the space available, there's a chance that Pandora's advertising revenue stream could offset its loss from extensive music playing. However, this option hides a chance of user turning away from the radio because of too many commercials.
2. A “freemium” model - that would provide a limited service to all users that would be free. They would, however, give the option to pay and have a premium-priced membership. It gets users the choice to make after experience the free version of Pandora as to whether or not they would like to subscribe.
3. A subscription model - that would spread the costs among the millions of users. This would make the costs very small. Pandora was thinking somewhere along the lines of $3 per customer which would lead the company to huge profit increase. However, this strategy does not distribute cost fairly to all consumers. Everyone does not stream music for the same length of time.
4. A “limited” model - the amount of hours available to stream would be set at 40 hours. Once you reach that limit, Pandora would ask you to pay 99 cents to continue on. Music listeners usually pay 99 cents per download. The 40 hours of music provides you with basically 600 songs.
The logical recommendation would be to go with the fourth option. This option is the most logical way and has the highest chance of success. Users really like Pandora and 99 cents will surely seem like a fair tradeoff for 40 hours of music or 600 songs. But also a freemium model makes a lot of sense. It guarantees a profit while maintaining a large customer base. This keeps the Pandora model as close as possible to what has been successful thus far, but opens the door for revenue by appealing to paying customers.
Reflection:
The Pinnacle Consulting Firm recommended several alternatives to pull Pandora out of their unfavorable situation. The recommendation to begin a Mobile application development, implement Tier structure (Freemium model) and utilize additional audio advertising space sounds enticing.
My recommendation would be to first utilize more of its advertising space and minimize non-stop carefree streaming which is causing the bulk of the profitability issues. Pandora has 60% advertising space available so the company will not be giving up anything by utilizing it. Pandora’s availability on all mobile platforms will also give them leverage since this allows companies the ability to target consumers through even more advertising outlets.
Tier structure seems like the way to go and a good way to raise profits but before making any critical decisions, I would like to recommend to Pandora one more possibility. I would suggested 40 free hours for Pandora listeners and charging them 99 cents after they went over that limit. I support this model the most because it requires very little upfront investment, it will certainly increase its revenue by charging only inefficient customers who leave their radio on for the whole day.
Pandora can also incorporate another option by allowing it to be free to a point, but after, say 40 hours you are capped out at the free version. So the user can either wait until they are reset at zero in the following time period, pays 99 cents to get another 40 hours or he/she can pay $3-4 for unlimited listening ability.
A combination of these courses of actions in the right order will help Pandora to gain more revenue and become profitable. This will place the company in a better financial position and increase the likelihood of receiving investments for future projects.