Bombardier Limited consists of two main divisions:
- Bombardier Aerospace is a world leader in the design and manufacture of innovative aviation products.
- Bombardier Transportation is the global leader in the rail equipment manufacturing and servicing industry.
The problem that Bombardier Aerospace faces is that it inherited data, processes and systems of each company it acquired. These different sets of data were hard to share among manufacturing facilities. Some areas of specific concern included, process delays, sequential activities, low inventory turns, supplier proliferation and price inconsistency, and multiple bills of material. Bombardier's main issue is that there was low visibility of inventory and a lack of integration between legacy systems.
Bombardier has chosen an Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) system as the best way to solve their problem.
Companies which build airplanes within a couple months or years should have an ERP system that manages inventory and can link a finances, accounting and business processes associated with building as big machine as an airplane. For Bombardier, an ERP system is necessary because of inventory management. A good IT system that can help manage which inventories need to be ordered as well as understanding which inventories are already in storage, is critical in the aerospace manufacturing industry. All business units need to talk to each other!
The first attempt to institute an ERP system in 2000 had to be discontinued due to failures caused by various factors such as focusing the implementation on the inappropriate business processes, an outdated company vision, a weak sponsorship model and insufficient involvement of internal employees. The second time, the ERP system integration become a success as Bombardier decided to change the approach and address the issues from the first attempt. Bombardier came up with the strategy that was not only successful in it’s implementation, but cost effective, meets the desired goals and was universally accepted by the businesses.
In 2001 Bombardier created a solid plan of selecting senior employees to show to the developers all of the important functions that were critical in being adopted in their new ERP system. To make sure, that they made a good decisions, small teams consisting of senior project directors were established to review the outputs and functionalities selected by senior employees to validate whether these system designs supported the overall objectives and strategies of the company. After the previous experience, it was critical that the ERP system was consistent with the corporate direction the company ultimately wanted to take. Next good step was that Bombardier decided to progressively implement the ERP software which provided a useful and supplemental strategy for employees as they were offered training classes before the ERP program was instituted. This helped insure that everyone would be ready for using the new ERP system.
All in all, it is obvious that the new ERP solution to the business problem was the needed solution, and the explanation to the first failed attempt related to poor planning and management involvement. Bombardier has implemented an integrated and streamlined workflow within its core business units that helps with its process, planning, production and quality assurance needed for an airplane manufacturing success.
I am interested in hearing the presentation of our consultants who will determine what the company could have done better, or worse.
If I were presenting I would develop flow charts for each process that will be eliminated with the new ERP system to show the C-Level team how efficient the new software is. I would sell the recommendation by advocating the efficiency of an ERP system. The process is not only faster and cheaper in the long term, but it is also highly productive, secure and precise.
Reflection:
According to a study presented by our consultants the second ERP implementation was a big success. However, after our discussion with consultants it is also very clear what areas Bombardier needs to improve in so that it can successfully roll out an ERP system the third time. The 12 Best Practices that were brought to our attention were an eye opener and Bombardier definitely could have improved in some aspects. Specifically with increasing cohesion between business functions and IT implementation, smoothing transition to new system, improving connection between contract management process and SAP system and reducing inefficiency costs.
As a member of the Bombardier's C-level team I would agree with recommended set of actions such as:
1. Include function specialists in design and implementation activities; Set in place formal process for accurate and real time scorecard progress; Diversify support team to include super users and function specialists along with IT.
2. Hire IT experts on a full time basis and phase out reliance on consultants but also implement SAP knowledge base in which employees can search.
3. Enhance SAP features to accommodate the current specialized contract management process and at the same time standardize the contract management process to conform with current SAP system features.
These actions will help to increase implementation efficiency, eliminate wasted costs, reduce productivity inefficiencies and increase overall profits.
Bombardier definitely needs to concentrate on training AFTER the ERP is implemented. A training on the system and its capabilities is unavoidable prior to the implementation, however a more specialized and deeper training for each employee after the implementation is also very important. Employees need to have the opportunity to meet with an ERP project experts to discuss their observations. Nobody knows an employees' necessities better than the employees themselves. This is the way how to make the whole process more effective and free up some time for the employee to do more analysis or ad-hoc projects that could benefit the firm.
I suggest to set up a committee who will work directly with the consultants in proffering exact solutions to these problem areas where Bombardier has been lacking. I think Bombardier needs to address issues immediately and provide support to the sites on a continuous basis. Overall, I think that Bombardier did a great job, but as the consultants did point out they can improve. There is always something to improve.