Thursday, April 18, 2013

Pandora


Pandora is an internet radio operated by Pandora Media, Inc.. It is fully available in the United States, Australia and New Zealand. The service plays musical selections of a certain genre based on the user's artist selection. The user then provides positive or negative feedback for songs chosen by the service, which are taken into account when Pandora selects future songs. Pandora previously switched from a subscription based model to a primarily free model with very limited subscriptions. Therefore, Pandora relies heavily on advertising for revenue. Other sources of revenue include the percentage of funds received from iTunes and Amazon purchases referred by Pandora. It has a successful model as far as number of customers, but it needs to find a way to convert that into profit. 

Year over year, Pandora has seen their bottom line shrink from a loss to even larger loss despite an increase in revenues. The context of its problem is how Pandora can become a profitable organization. To make this happen, Pandora needs to keep its regular customers, attract new ones and cover its expenses including operating costs and royalties.

The problem is, that its listeners are the most expensive elements because Pandora has to pay royalties on a per song basis. The "non-stop carefree streaming" is costing Pandora a lot of money. Listeners do not care whether they left the program running and playing songs or not.

Alternative Courses of Action (or nicely being said: What Pandora can do?)

1. Add more advertising and marketing - by using information obtained from the registration process, it could provide target marketing as well as local marketing and maximize advertising opportunities. Pandora is only using about 60% of their available advertising space. By maximizing the space available, there's a chance that Pandora's advertising revenue stream could offset its loss from extensive music playing. However, this option hides a chance of user turning away from the radio because of too many commercials.
2. A “freemium” model - that would provide a limited service to all users that would be free. They would, however, give the option to pay and have a premium-priced membership. It gets users the choice to make after experience the free version of Pandora as to whether or not they would like to subscribe.
3. A subscription model - that would spread the costs among the millions of users. This would make the costs very small. Pandora was thinking somewhere along the lines of $3 per customer which would lead the company to huge profit increase. However, this strategy does not distribute cost fairly to all consumers. Everyone does not stream music for the same length of time.
4. A “limited” model - the amount of hours available to stream would be set at 40 hours. Once you reach that limit, Pandora would ask you to pay 99 cents to continue on. Music listeners usually pay 99 cents per download. The 40 hours of music provides you with basically 600 songs.

The logical recommendation would be to go with the fourth option. This option is the most logical way and has the highest chance of success. Users really like Pandora and 99 cents will surely seem like a fair tradeoff for 40 hours of music or 600 songs. But also a freemium model makes a lot of sense. It guarantees a profit while maintaining a large customer base. This keeps the Pandora model as close as possible to what has been successful thus far, but opens the door for revenue by appealing to paying customers. 


Reflection:

The Pinnacle Consulting Firm recommended several alternatives to pull Pandora out of their unfavorable situation. The recommendation to begin a Mobile application development, implement Tier structure (Freemium model) and utilize additional audio advertising space sounds enticing.

My recommendation would be to first utilize more of its advertising space and minimize non-stop carefree streaming which is causing the bulk of the profitability issues. Pandora has 60% advertising space available so the company will not be giving up anything by utilizing it. Pandora’s availability on all mobile platforms will also give them leverage since this allows companies the ability to target consumers through even more advertising outlets.

Tier structure seems like the way to go and a good way to raise profits but before making any critical decisions, I would like to recommend to Pandora one more possibility. I would suggested 40 free hours for Pandora listeners and charging them 99 cents after they went over that limit. I support this model the most because it requires very little upfront investment, it will certainly increase its revenue by charging only inefficient customers who leave their radio on for the whole day.

Pandora can also incorporate another option by allowing it to be free to a point, but after, say 40 hours you are capped out at the free version. So the user can either wait until they are reset at zero in the following time period, pays 99 cents to get another 40 hours or he/she can pay $3-4 for unlimited listening ability.

A combination of these courses of actions in the right order will help Pandora to gain more revenue and become profitable. This will place the company in a better financial position and increase the likelihood of receiving investments for future projects.

Sunday, March 31, 2013

Microsoft Project



Microsoft Project (MSP) is software which gives project managers powerful ways to effectively manage important projects. It is easier way how to keep projects organized and on track. A key benefit is the ability to assign financial resources to every stage of a project, keep a timeline, make some estimates and to hand in to management on a regular basis. 

Microsoft Project Version
Professional 2013
Standard 2013
online
Price
$1159.99
$589.99
$33-$45 per user/month
Mostly intended for:
project managers who work in such a capacity
project managers who don't need collaborative tools
project managers who prefer a flexible, time limited and less expensive online solution

MSP has a positive impact on businesses. Companies can save time and money on projects. For example, a wedding planner, without the MSP would either have to hire somebody or herself have to spend the requisite time trying to integrate, estimate, and assign resources to various aspect of the wedding. Let's say that 4 labor hours can be saved per week. Time is money so 4 x $30/hr = $120 x 52 weeks = $6240 a year. On larger projects, the time and money saved will be even more. It saves time for employees through automated processes, gains more visibility into projects, and improved resource management.

To learn, how this software works is very often a time consuming. I would recommended to any purchaser not familiar with MSP to take advantage of the free tutorials on You Tube and download quick manuals and templates. There is a lot of information, tips and manuals online. Among other things, the price for 2 days of training which can help to get the most productivity from MSP software is around $700. Plus the loss on working time is 2 days x 8hr x $30 = $480. With purchase of MSP Professional ($1159.99) it is still better choice to involve this software into the project process even only for one year.

If your company doesn’t need Microsoft Project’s "super-power", you may want to use Clarizen or Zoho project. If you need industrial strength project budgeting MSP may be the best and only alternative. MSP includes every project management feature users have come to expect. With the familiar Microsoft look and feel, Microsoft Project has it all. Coupled with Microsoft SharePoint, Project has collaboration capabilities that surpass almost anything offered by its upstart rivals.

Thursday, March 21, 2013

Bombardier - a Large-Scale ERP Implemenation


Bombardier Limited consists of two main divisions:
  1. Bombardier Aerospace is a world leader in the design and manufacture of innovative aviation products.
  2. Bombardier Transportation is the global leader in the rail equipment manufacturing and servicing industry.
The problem that Bombardier Aerospace faces is that it inherited data, processes and systems of each company it acquired. These different sets of data were hard to share among manufacturing facilities. Some areas of specific concern included, process delays, sequential activities, low inventory turns, supplier proliferation and price inconsistency, and multiple bills of material. Bombardier's main issue is that there was low visibility of inventory and a lack of integration between legacy systems.

Bombardier has chosen an Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) system as the best way to solve their problem.

Companies which build airplanes within a couple months or years should have an ERP system that manages inventory and can link a finances, accounting and business processes associated with building as big machine as an airplane. For Bombardier, an ERP system is necessary because of inventory management. A good IT system that can help manage which inventories need to be ordered as well as understanding which inventories are already in storage, is critical in the aerospace manufacturing industry. All business units need to talk to each other!

The first attempt to institute an ERP system in 2000 had to be discontinued due to failures caused by various factors such as focusing the implementation on the inappropriate business processes, an outdated company vision, a weak sponsorship model and insufficient involvement of internal employees. The second time, the ERP system integration become a success as Bombardier decided to change the approach and address the issues from the first attempt. Bombardier came up with the strategy that was not only successful in it’s implementation, but cost effective, meets the desired goals and was universally accepted by the businesses.

In 2001 Bombardier created a solid plan of selecting senior employees to show to the developers all of the important functions that were critical in being adopted in their new ERP system. To make sure, that they made a good decisions, small teams consisting of senior project directors were established to review the outputs and functionalities selected by senior employees to validate whether these system designs supported the overall objectives and strategies of the company. After the previous experience, it was critical that the ERP system was consistent with the corporate direction the company ultimately wanted to take. Next good step was that Bombardier decided to progressively implement the ERP software which provided a useful and supplemental strategy for employees as they were offered training classes before the ERP program was instituted. This helped insure that everyone would be ready for using the new ERP system.

All in all, it is obvious that the new ERP solution to the business problem was the needed solution, and the explanation to the first failed attempt related to poor planning and management involvement. Bombardier has implemented an integrated and streamlined workflow within its core business units that helps with its process, planning, production and quality assurance needed for an airplane manufacturing success.

I am interested in hearing the presentation of our consultants who will determine what the company could have done better, or worse.

If I were presenting I would develop flow charts for each process that will be eliminated with the new ERP system to show the C-Level team how efficient the new software is. I would sell the recommendation by advocating the efficiency of an ERP system. The process is not only faster and cheaper in the long term, but it is also highly productive, secure and precise.


Reflection:

According to a study presented by our consultants the second ERP implementation was a big success. However, after our discussion with consultants it is also very clear what areas Bombardier needs to improve in so that it can successfully roll out an ERP system the third time. The 12 Best Practices that were brought to our attention were an eye opener and Bombardier definitely could have improved in some aspects. Specifically with increasing cohesion between business functions and IT implementation, smoothing transition to new system, improving connection between contract management process and SAP system and reducing inefficiency costs.

As a member of the Bombardier's C-level team I would agree with recommended set of actions such as:
1. Include function specialists in design and implementation activities; Set in place formal process for accurate and real time scorecard progress; Diversify support team to include super users and function specialists along with IT.
2. Hire IT experts on a full time basis and phase out reliance on consultants but also implement SAP knowledge base in which employees can search.
3. Enhance SAP features to accommodate the current specialized contract management process and at the same time standardize the contract management process to conform with current SAP system features.

These actions will help to increase implementation efficiency, eliminate wasted costs, reduce productivity inefficiencies and increase overall profits.

Bombardier definitely needs to concentrate on training AFTER the ERP is implemented. A training on the system and its capabilities is unavoidable prior to the implementation, however a more specialized and deeper training for each employee after the implementation is also very important. Employees need to have the opportunity to meet with an ERP project experts to discuss their observations. Nobody knows an employees' necessities better than the employees themselves. This is the way how to make the whole process more effective and free up some time for the employee to do more analysis or ad-hoc projects that could benefit the firm.

I suggest to set up a committee who will work directly with the consultants in proffering exact solutions to these problem areas where Bombardier has been lacking. I think Bombardier needs to address issues immediately and provide support to the sites on a continuous basis. Overall, I think that Bombardier did a great job, but as the consultants did point out they can improve. There is always something to improve.

Monday, March 4, 2013

Strategic IT Transformation at Accenture

In 2001, Andersen Consulting separated from the parent company Arthur Andersen and was renamed Accenture. Accenture is a global management consulting, technology services and outsourcing company which faced with a problem, how does it make the transition from working under the existing IT system of its former parent company, Arthur Andersen, to a standalone world class IT organization with its own IT system. They had only a year to create and implement their new system. Accenture could not and did not want to use the IT system, that Arthur Andersen had, because it was not sufficient for a newly established company that prided itself on providing corporations guidance to adopt efficient business processes that enhance operational performance.

They had two alternative courses of action:
1. Decentralized approach - each country chose its own IT platforms and had the autonomy to run them. The unit could potentially maintain the lead in the market place by implementing the latest technology. This approach will not be cost effective due to the licensing fees and maintenance cost. Running multiple applications across the firm would require multiple specialists resulting in increase the training costs and the additional support. It will also affect the ability to share information among other units.
2. Centralized approach - all offices interconnected on the same "instance" of a software platform. This approach will have the advantage of dealing with one or couple vendors to meet its application needs. Accenture would be able to gain discounts in licensing fees and maintenance. It could reduce costs for training and support. In addition, company will be able to extract any information at any given time since all the interfaces will be interconnected. However, the downside will be the inability to negotiate with the vendor regarding to the future purchases.

Accenture eventually chose the centralized approach and to eliminate some risk went with one of the biggest and most financially secure software companies - Microsoft. They have done a good job implementing of the SAP platform as well. The one platform approach and outsourcing of its non-critical IT support, adapted by Accenture, was a rather ambitious tactic with great potential. Accenture created a strategic and cost effective system with the most advanced technologies. I definitely agree with the choice of the centralized approach especially in a business that is looking to foster communication between its global offices.

Accenture depends on information and a significant part of its market value is made up of intangible assets. They have done great job in overhauling their outdated IT system into a new centralized platform. They have invested significant resources in information technology as an enabler to achieve strategic goals. What else should they do? In my opinion, Accenture should adopt an IT governance framework that would manage its new IT system. Effective corporate governance should ensure that IT projects are aligned to corporate objectives and that IT expenditure is appropriate for the business requirements. Companies like Accenture are more and more dependent on their information systems. Regulators and the public are increasingly concerned about the proper use of information, particularly personal data. Accenture's information needs to be protected through corporate governance plans as part of its system of internal control.

If I were presenting this case I would focus on what impact alternative decision could have been for the company such as choosing the decentralized approach and I would present visual aids that clearly display the added value an IT governance framework would provide.

Reflection:


After hearing Strategic IT Consulting's presentation, I stand firm in my recommendation that adopting an IT governance framework is needed in order to take Accenture to the next level. Although Accenture has done an excellent job building a new IT infrastructure from the ground up, there is always room for improvement. 

I would like to stand behind our consultants' recommendation. I think that Accenture should implement the CobiT5 framework. Implementing CobiT5 will be beneficial in solving their problem of finding the best method to manage their technology platforms and IT infrastructure. For a global company like Accenture, issues related to security, data auditing, information control and governance, can negatively impact business by losing client credibility, levied tariffs from regulatory agencies and lawsuit due to security lapses. Consultants arguments provide many valid post as to why CobiT5 is good option. 

CobiT5 is one of the premier standards that provides guidance on compliance issues. It can help maintain high-quality information to support business decisions, achieve strategic goals and realize business benefits through the effective and innovative use of IT, achieve operational excellence through reliable, efficient application of technology, maintain IT-related risk at an acceptable level, optimize the cost of IT services and technology and support compliance with relevant laws, regulations, contractual agreements and policies. Given the need for Accenture to reduce costs and also treat its routing of doing business as a profit center, rather then a cost center, this fully addresses those needs.

Accenture can start by hiring CobiT certified personnel as needed in order to get hands on insight on how the CobiT framework can impact the company. From there a decision can be made to adopt the framework based on the results.

Finally, I think Accenture should adopt the CobiT 5 as this will be their advantage in the long-run and it does seem to be reasonable.



Tuesday, February 26, 2013

Zara: IT for Fast Fashion


Inditex is a holding company atop clothing chain called Zara. Zara`s operating system still runs on DOS. DOS (Disk Operating System) was the first widely-installed operating system for personal computers. Zara is worried about its IT infrastructure being too old and the possibility that hardware vendors will upgrade their "computers" leaving them unsuited with DOS.

Zara's operations rely on its POS (the point-of-sale) terminals which are used by each store, all over the world. One of the problem is that these terminals inside a store do not communicate with any other terminals. Only one terminal for each store has ability to communicate with headquarters in La Coruna. Also, Personal Digital Assistants (PDA) used to complete the ordering process are not connected in any way to the POS terminals. As a result, Zara has the lack of ability to check inventory within stores. Instead of using a modern system that updates inventory in real time when items are scanned for sale or return, employees have to search in shelves and count their inventories. This is time consuming and inaccurate.

Zara has three alternatives:

  1. Staying with the POS terminals - Zara can stay with the original system since the POS terminals with DOS works very well. As Sanchez said: "POS is not broken, why are we trying to fix it?" The benefit with staying with the current system is that it is stable and requires less IT support. 
  2. Upgrading the POS terminals - The benefits of upgrading the system do not outweigh the costs. The costs include the new terminals and new software. Zara should not forget to count with the cost of switching to the new system, retraining the current employees, and hiring a full time IT staff to maintain a new system. 
  3. Replacing the POS terminals - Zara can change the whole IT system that will improve communication between stores, reduce floppy disk use, and allow using of new features. However, the system will be a big investment for Zara. The cost will be very high because they will have to find a new vendor, install the new system, train employees, and it will lead to a drastic change.

My recommendation for the company would be to change their operational system. Although DOS works well for them, the future is not in it. It makes them dependent of their hardware vendor and opening a new store may become risky if they cannot provide it with the same hardware tools. A new system will support employees with more information and it will increase efficiency. Zara should implement changes slowly in an effort to make the transition easier. The initial cost of the investment may be substantial but the return on investment gained from increased operational efficiency over time will outweigh these costs. Zara must find an alternative that works best with the criteria that it is concerned with while also allowing for Zara to accomplish its goals. Since the alternatives are laid out, Zara must do their research to see which alternative theoretically fits them best.

If I were presenting, I would explain Zara's operations and prepare cost-benefit analysis to see if replacing the old POS system would be beneficial.

Reflection:

After the presentation of our consultants, I still think that even though Zara has no problem with POS system itself at its current status, the innovations will require Zara to upgrade it. For a fast growing company like Zara, I would reccommended to improve their system now rather than waiting until they actually hit a problem. I would recommended this investment by explaining the possible future risks and what can happen if Zara would have to switch out their technology at last minute. I believe ZARA will be able to achieve improvement with new technology. For example, this change will allow for online sites and create better and faster inventory updates. It will also connect all of ZARA’s chain stores. Some of the benefits will allow Zara to better manage and predict demand. As long as ZARA can adapt to this technology the way they want, they may be able to keep their tradition of person to person interaction with customers, and at the same time, be more efficient at helping and getting them what they want. During the integration process it may be helpful for Zara to introduce the new infrastructure by country. The IT department will need to hire and train new and current employees in order to make a successful transition. The following step will be updating their operation system, hence in the future the question could be "how do we continue to be successful" instead of "how do we solve our old system problem"?!


Sunday, February 24, 2013

Ubuntu


I came to work yesterday with piece of paper in my hand. I walked straight to my boss office, showed him that paper, and said "Why do we pay for something what we could get for free?" I was talking about Ubuntu. Ubuntu is operation system which has become the most popular Linux distribution on personal computers. Moreover, it is also popular on servers, for cloud computing and will be available for smartphones. One misconceptions is that Linux is complicated and hard to use. No it is not, it is so easy to use and free of charge!

We are small private company with twenty employees. Every year we hire at least one or two more people. Every single employee is highly educated and needs a personal computer. It is time to do the math:


OS
What do we use/need?
processor and RAM requirements
software
drivers
security
How much it cost per computer?
Microsoft Windows
a minimum of 1000 Mhz processor with 1GB of RAM



$520 Dell computer with Windows 7
MS Office





$220
need to download the drivers manually


Technician hourly rate $20
a weak operating system from a security standpoint

roughly $30 a year
$790
Linux Ubuntu
a minimum of 700 Mhz processor with 384MB RAM


$420 Dell computer without OS
LibreOffice




free of charge
built-in driver set



Technician hourly rate $20
offers much more security by default


roughly $30 a year
$450
Which one is better for our company?
Ubuntu’s performance is higher so we can keep old computers longer
Ubuntu’s LibreOffice is free of charge
Ubuntu requires less maintenance hours
Ubuntu, even though we can get an antivirus program at the same price
the winner is Ubuntu
Saved money per computer
$100
$220
$20
$0
$340

If we will migrate from Microsoft Office to alternative solution to save money a we will move our users over to LibreOffice, there might be some initial confusions. Naturally, when we make this switch, our employees will need to know a few best practices to avoid the typical migration pitfalls. Couple tips will help ease the transition, therefore; we can arrange a special training for this purpose. If we are really serious about cutting our desktop costs, Linux is the way to go.

Monday, February 18, 2013

1-888-JUNK-VAN


In 2009, 1-888-JUNK-VAN began to grow after only one year of operation. This junk removal business expanded from one man and a truck, to a multi-city full service company. It achieved success using a virtual business model (without a physical headquarter); however, as the company grew, inefficiencies and errors also increased and 1-888-JUNK-VAN was losing customers. Founder Marcus Kingo realized that he needed to implement a fast and reliable system to run and organize his growing business.

Kingo and his employees were using Microsoft Works, and emailing the updated data back and forth. The operators had to contact the drivers via phone or email every time a new reservation was made. When 1-888-JUNK-VAN started receiving more phone calls, it was no longer workable and it soon grew to a point of the daily frustrations. For reservations made in advance, distribution schedules were manually created and emailed out individually every night. Also, stuff payroll had become a difficult task. Drivers had to write their daily work hours, and then email them to a payroll coordinator. Then the data were organized and sent to Kingo for approval and payment. The whole process required a lot of time to ensure that all the data were correct and to rectify all errors in the database which caused a delay in business because company could not take anymore appointments until the database was repaired. 

Marcus Kingo had five alternative courses of action from which to choose: a database upgrade, contracting out development of a new software application, using Google Docs, using an online tool framed as Platform as a Service (PaaS), or implementing a small-business enterprise resource-planning (ERP) system. Each option presents strengths and weaknesses, and me and my colleagues are left to make a decision on which one will be the most preferable.

1. Microsoft Access Database - implementing Microsoft Access Database would be relatively easy, less time consuming and less expensive. Support can be easily available as it is a very common database. However, the biggest disadvantage of using Microsoft Access is that remote access does not exist and it will require people with database skills to operate.
2. Custom Application - It will help to have centralized database, and at the same time the software can be customized to specifically address the underlying operational problems and company's needs. Disadvantage of using a custom application designed for 1-888-JUNK-VAN is that it is not only time consuming but also a success is uncertain.
3. Google Docs - It is free and easy to use. It has great features like sharing, collaboration and auto-saving; however, the disadvantage of using Google Docs is the lack of security. Company will not be able to implement any security measure to safeguard the company’s private and sensitive data.
4. Platform as a Service (PaaS) - It is a cloud-computing infrastructure. Data can be shared and accessed anytime and anywhere, which makes it convenient for anyone. It can have multiple users using the same integrated application environment at the same time, thus giving much needed scalability to the company. It is not an expensive option with no contracts and can be migrated in as little as 3 days. I don’t see any disadvantages in using PaaS if I compare it with other options.
5. Enterprise Resource Planning System (ERP) - It has huge upfront cost but it will provide the company with everything it needs in terms of its IT requirement. ERP system is built around one central database and can be accessed remotely. Along with being very expensive, many of its features and functions may not be needed by 1-888-JUNK-VAN.

Despite all of the options, I believe that the best one will be a PaaS system implementation. This is the most affordable option that company will be able to optimize and use over time. They will receive vendor support when needed and the platform will be able to change and grow to match the needs of the evolving organization. This is the logically recommendation because it fits most of the criteria for making a decision at an affordable pricing option. With onsite trial, Kingo was already able to see what his end product will be; therefore, in my opinion, after deploying PaaS, 1-888-JUNK-VAN would be able to roll-out a series of fully customized apps to meet the company’s needs.

Reflection:

After attending meeting with the consultants, Platform as a Service (PaaS) was recommended as the solution to 1-888-JUNK-VAN operational inefficiency. However, PaaS, described in the case is actually a Software as a Service (SaaS). SaaS is a specific online software solution such as ADP or also Facebook where you can basically sign in and work. On the other hand, PaaS is kind of base services that contains required features to host many different type of online softwares including SaaS applications. On the basis of new circumstances, I would recommend that Marcus Kingo select the SaaS solution to move forward. It provides remote access, ability to create custom applications which would address both a scheduling efficiency and routing optimization need and possibly a payroll needs, provides one central database that can be edited by multiple users. It is flexible and easy to use and provides vendor support.