In 2009, 1-888-JUNK-VAN began to grow after only one year of operation. This junk removal business expanded from one man and a truck, to a multi-city full service company. It achieved success using a virtual business model (without a physical headquarter); however, as the company grew, inefficiencies and errors also increased and 1-888-JUNK-VAN was losing customers. Founder Marcus Kingo realized that he needed to implement a fast and reliable system to run and organize his growing business.
Kingo and his employees were using Microsoft Works, and emailing the updated data back and forth. The operators had to contact the drivers via phone or email every time a new reservation was made. When 1-888-JUNK-VAN started receiving more phone calls, it was no longer workable and it soon grew to a point of the daily frustrations. For reservations made in advance, distribution schedules were manually created and emailed out individually every night. Also, stuff payroll had become a difficult task. Drivers had to write their daily work hours, and then email them to a payroll coordinator. Then the data were organized and sent to Kingo for approval and payment. The whole process required a lot of time to ensure that all the data were correct and to rectify all errors in the database which caused a delay in business because company could not take anymore appointments until the database was repaired.
Marcus Kingo had five alternative courses of action from which to choose: a database upgrade, contracting out development of a new software application, using Google Docs, using an online tool framed as Platform as a Service (PaaS), or implementing a small-business enterprise resource-planning (ERP) system. Each option presents strengths and weaknesses, and me and my colleagues are left to make a decision on which one will be the most preferable.
1. Microsoft Access Database - implementing Microsoft Access Database would be relatively easy, less time consuming and less expensive. Support can be easily available as it is a very common database. However, the biggest disadvantage of using Microsoft Access is that remote access does not exist and it will require people with database skills to operate.
2. Custom Application - It will help to have centralized database, and at the same time the software can be customized to specifically address the underlying operational problems and company's needs. Disadvantage of using a custom application designed for 1-888-JUNK-VAN is that it is not only time consuming but also a success is uncertain.
3. Google Docs - It is free and easy to use. It has great features like sharing, collaboration and auto-saving; however, the disadvantage of using Google Docs is the lack of security. Company will not be able to implement any security measure to safeguard the company’s private and sensitive data.
4. Platform as a Service (PaaS) - It is a cloud-computing infrastructure. Data can be shared and accessed anytime and anywhere, which makes it convenient for anyone. It can have multiple users using the same integrated application environment at the same time, thus giving much needed scalability to the company. It is not an expensive option with no contracts and can be migrated in as little as 3 days. I don’t see any disadvantages in using PaaS if I compare it with other options.
5. Enterprise Resource Planning System (ERP) - It has huge upfront cost but it will provide the company with everything it needs in terms of its IT requirement. ERP system is built around one central database and can be accessed remotely. Along with being very expensive, many of its features and functions may not be needed by 1-888-JUNK-VAN.
Despite all of the options, I believe that the best one will be a PaaS system implementation. This is the most affordable option that company will be able to optimize and use over time. They will receive vendor support when needed and the platform will be able to change and grow to match the needs of the evolving organization. This is the logically recommendation because it fits most of the criteria for making a decision at an affordable pricing option. With onsite trial, Kingo was already able to see what his end product will be; therefore, in my opinion, after deploying PaaS, 1-888-JUNK-VAN would be able to roll-out a series of fully customized apps to meet the company’s needs.
Reflection:
Reflection:
After attending meeting with the consultants, Platform as a Service (PaaS) was recommended as the solution to 1-888-JUNK-VAN operational inefficiency. However, PaaS, described in the case is actually a Software as a Service (SaaS). SaaS is a specific online software solution such as ADP or also Facebook where you can basically sign in and work. On the other hand, PaaS is kind of base services that contains required features to host many different type of online softwares including SaaS applications. On the basis of new circumstances, I would recommend that Marcus Kingo select the SaaS solution to move forward. It provides remote access, ability to create custom applications which would address both a scheduling efficiency and routing optimization need and possibly a payroll needs, provides one central database that can be edited by multiple users. It is flexible and easy to use and provides vendor support.
No comments:
Post a Comment